What is a Lower Interval Limit? | Q+A #52



Download videos:


Also…..What is a good Audiation Exercise? What about Octave UP pedals on bass? Why is Ionian major and not Lydian? and more!Many thanks to Valentin Yacante, Jarf510, Houssein Nazeran Pour, RoseGuyCrazy, Waluigi chan, Jukka Pesonen, and Jordan Buck for their insightful questions!Peace,Adam



Tags:
bass fusion guitar jazz lesson music neely theory adam


Akenani Menatseah
You look different somehow...
Alex Dallas
i'm loving the anti-clickbait thumbnails
Alexander Chellsen
For Q&A:\n\nI want to learn music from the ground up, but I don’t know where to start. I’ve been playing music by ear for about four years now, but I want to attribute understanding to what I’ve been playing. What essential beginner’s guide do you recommend? I love your videos, but I know there is a lot that goes over my head.
AnSoR
Adam, speaking of the \
Ananth D
How long a piece can you audiate? I often find that I can audiate 15-30 seconds in my head quite well, but not entire songs/pieces.
Andu Ninicu
that silent memes ... beautiful editing on this one !!!
ApplepieFTW
Adam, how about the maximum \
Ariel Yemini
Hi Adam I'm your second view please like me I need appreciation from others to feel worthy as a human beingggggg
Austin Vestal
Adam, Question for your next Q&A:\n\nI learned just a couple years ago that I have Aphantasia, a condition where I cannot picture things in my mind's eye and in turn, audiate. I've been playing stringed instruments for 15 years, and have played electric and upright for 13 years, and around then I remember being able to visualize. Is there anything that I can do work on or potentially reclaim my ability to audiate? I've always been able to understand chords and how to play within them, because they've always been mathematical and bound by rules, but I've only recently been able to start to grasp how to solo and play melodically and I can't help but feel held back by my inability to hear things in my own head. \n\nThank you for everything that you do, your channel has been a huge inspiration for me to keep pushing forward with my bass playing and become a better musician.\n\nAustin
AwwwMannn
Your eyes suddenly look blue
Ayaan Raza
Question for the Next Q&A\n\n\nHow can an intermediate musician become a hyper technical musician (very odd time signatures, complicated rhythms, and being able to fast licks)? \n\nBTW, I love your videos and you were really influential in my decision to buy and start learning bass, thanks.
B7 Music Studio
Maybe a simpler explanation for Ionian/Aeolian: The tritone RESOLVES TO a major third. The only triads with those notes are I or vi.
BAwesomeDesign
\
Bob Gooday
Hey Adam, \nIf you listen to old recordings of blues and Appalachian singers (for example Robert Johnson or Dock Boggs), their voices sound a bit sort of 'flat'. Is this something to do with recording systems, their approach to tuning, or is it more of a musical 'accent'?
BradGatton
5:42 Can you play the rest of MacGyver plz
Bøø9
Question for future Q&A: Why is texture/timbre so closely linked with genre (at least in popular music)? Even subgenres have recognizable textures/timbres distinct from other subgenres in the same main genre.
CHS Music
Adam, who are you playing with at Guinness Jazz festival in Cork Ireland? Thanks man
Chad Thompson
Oh crap, someone just learned how to key in his video editor.
Colin Duncan Music
If a chord sounds muddy, just get new pickups. Duh.
Conner Farrell
Do you have any advice for guitar players who are trying to transition from playing with a pick to with their fingers? Also any advice on learning to solo across the fretboard, rather than just in a box, Thanks!
Daniel Diaz
LOL. Despacito IS NOT Daddy Yankee's best work. Also, hair is on point. #fuego
Davie504
After despacito 2, we need the *LICC* *2* please release it asap
Deko Parra
listen adam speaking spanish was muy excitante
Denni Wintyr
Black Sabbath would be good for audiation, as the guitar, bass & drums are often doing very different things.\nMusic in schools: Because the arts are literally the thing that makes us human... imagine the world without music... pretty horrific (unless you're a sociopath)
DerSibbe
For your next Q&A: What's your opinion on New Complexity Music and Composers like Ferneyhough, Xenakis and Finnissy? Also, could you talk a bit about their composing techniques and how they get to write such complex music?
Dliess Mgg
For the next QnA:\n\nAs far as I understand it, the licc became a meme because someone noticed that many jazz musicians used it everywhere. Why did it become so widely used? Is it because of certain melodic/harmonic properties that it has?
Dragonboar Productions
honestly adam is lookin like a thicc little hipster boy in this one
Drew Mac
That part about the Ionian and Aeolian modes, and their I chord's absence of tritone with other notes blew my mind!
Eli Porter
Question for your next QnA:\n\nHey Adam, I'm a multi-instrumentalist considering music school. How should I choose what instrument to pursue or how can I persue all of them?
Erómeon
10:00 yeah. Because \
Final Score
I found it really easy to audiate the guitar on that song you did with Gear Gods... mostly because it was doing the exact same as the bass. Video was excellent and informative as always.
Game Dev Made Easy
Hey Adam, What would you say are the fundamental differences between how bassist, guitarist and pianist approach scales, chords and key signatures when composing music?
HUNTER AWP
Did you just rekt djent as a whole?
Helium Road
Presence of cat detected. Automatic thumbs up.
Isah bd
I got 600 likes and wasnt featured in yiay
Jake Guitar Guy
practices auditation for All Star\nget all the parts down pretty well\nstart to audiate the guitar parts in my head\n*nice*\nswitch to the bass so I can get that down better\na few days pass and I finally get it down really good\ngets stuck in my head*\n*wAIT*
Jonas Daverio
For a future Q&A :\nI'm a classical music student from Switzerland. I'm getting interested in other genre than just classical music, but I've actually got this feeling with jazz that it sometimes sounds good, sometimes not (purely subjectively), but I never quiet understand it. I've sometimes got the impression that jazz harmony is just random chords that magically sound good together, but I can't understand them with just what I know.\nWhat could I do, learn, etc., to understand it better?\nIt sometimes scares me a little, I've got like the feeling that jazz is to hard for me, that I couldn't get into it. I would like to see jazz (and other related genres) as natural as classical music is for me.\n\n(It's funny, from what I see, some classical musicians are convinced that classical music is the most advanced music in the world, but I'm sure they couldn't understand some music any better than me, and by that I mean, not at all).
Juho Pitkäranta
I have to say I’m not fully convinced by your marks on the ionian/aeolian thing. Yes, this is very subjective, but in my opinion F is a lot more dissonant than F# over a C major chord. Same thing with the A minor chord.
Justin Y.
Time to get educated.
KevinOu456
I love how you do the opposite of clickbait and literally put the answer in the thumbnail
LongNightsInOffice
Going hand in hand with learning an instrument is reflecting about the own learning processes and trying to optimize it. In other words you learn how you learn more efficently
Luke Abbott
The name of the Dembow rhythm comes from the name of the song \
Mathbook Hero
For a future Q&A:\n I know you've anwsered the question \
MaxMAJFC
i like your hair adam neely
Meme Thief
Dembow is a song by shabba ranks, a dancehall song relevant to the history of reggae\n\nAlso, Mike Kerr of Royal Blood pitch shifts his second bass signal to achieve distorted guitar tone, allowing him and his mate to make rock with just two people
Naveh Raz
9:09 In the middle east it's commonly known as the \
Neil G. Dickson
I've watched so many of these in the past few weeks, my first thought was \
Niko ck
Monday is my favorite day
PH7Neutral__
In relation to the octave up on a bass to play lead like a guitar you should listen to royal blood, they’re a bass and drum duo and are big in the UK. The bassist uses a pick and two lines, one goes to a bass amp with an octave up and other pedals while the other goes to a guitar amp with an octave down pedal. The two octave shifts (up and down) blend together but he also plays some moments with one line or the other
Pero Brittz
That new jazzy licc though
Powder Ganger
O dad your hair is beautiful.
RC32
Oh man, I missed the classic Adam Neely Schooling and information! Great video my friend!\n\nAlso that Lick composition tho
Rainbow Llamas
oooo new licc harmonization.
Richard Atkinson
It depends a lot on the timbre of the low notes. Sine waves from a synthesizer likely sound “harmonic” at much lower registers than trombones.
Ruben Madar
Hey Adam, for the next Q+A,\n\nCould you explained the harmony behind \
Shan M
B A S S
Shymain
Re: the question about playing bass an octave up, this is exactly what the band Royal Blood does. They've got two members, a bassist/singer and a drummer, and the bassist uses an octaver plus some other complicated pedal/amp chains to get a distorted guitar-esque sound and it sounds fantastic. I've got a friend that's learned every bassline of theirs to perfection, pedal chain and all, and it's a ridiculously cool sound.
Signals Music Studio
I never realized the lack of tritone relationships in Major/Minor.... Very cool and thanks again!
Skip6235
So, I was trained as a musician on the Suzuki method from a very young age (for those who don't know it is a method of teaching young kids string instruments by starting them playing by ear and then introducing them to written music once they get the fundamentals down). It literally never occurred to me until I watched this video that audiation (sp?) isn't a thing that everyone does. I just innately remember all the parts of a song and when I think back to it or it's stuck in my head, it \
Smooth.
you need a haircut my man
Tark McCoy
Adam: What's your opinion on parents who push an instrument on a child to learn that the child has no interest in?
TellerOfUntruths
Here’s a question:\n\nIs audition more important in some instruments than others? I played Clarinet for years but was never told to visualize the note I was playing, but I briefly switched to French Horn and one of the things that was very important was auditing the note before playing it (this was from a guest instructor.) I didn’t play FH long enough to really find out, but does this hold any merit??
TheOnyxLord
L I C C IFICATION SQUAD
Thelonious Funk
I love what you said in the last minute.
Thingaloo
Hairdam Neely looks cuter by the video :)
Thomas Carmichael
What are the details on your appearance at the Cork Jazz Festival in October? The website and social media for the festival is painfully low on details and info.
TimmyM
You're so darned groovy.
Todesnuss
If lower interval limits are dependent on overtones wouldn't less overtone rich instruments have lower limits? A clean sine subbass could just go down as far as you want.
Tonhueb
I liked the part where your cat walked over the rite of spring.
Vect
the fact that adam knows a lot of reggaeton amazes me
Will Tannery
Is height, and by extension finger length, a limiting factor in my development as a bass player? \n\nI have a distinct memory of being eight or nine and saying “I want to play bass!” and then my sister told me I was too small. I’m seventeen now and I’ve been playing bass for about six months, but I can’t help but fear my short stature (5’2) is limiting my playing.
WillHissettBeats
Of course I can remember the bassline to All Star!
William Romig
Hey Adam, a question for you, what is the difference between bebop, hard bop, post bop, and kids bop.
Wood Pigeon
Pigeon
Yaye
@Adam Neely\nDembow is the dominican version of reggaeton.\nBoth are incredibly similar are mistakable for each other, but never tell a Puerto Rican or Dominican that.
Yield
appreciate you giving the answer to the question in the thumbnail
YoshiThe1st
When the star wars theme melody was on screen, I wasn't lisening for a second, so I never heard you saying that I had to imagine the Star Wars theme. After 2 bars however, I got that it was the theme, and I was able to hear everything in my head, from the percussion, to the bass, to the melody and everything in between. (I'm 17 right now, so I was never exposed alot to the theme sadly) When you asked to recall what the bass, guitar and drums play in All Star, I could recall those quite well, despite not hearing it more than anyone else. I seem to remember the individual parts of a song rather quickly. Maybe all the time I spent composing and arranging has improved this ability?
Zach Rowe
Is there an upper interval limit?
ZipplyZane
Don't the lower interval limits also depend on the instrument? I'm pretty sure I've hear low brass or male choruses sing intervals that sound too muddy on a piano.
alex santini
question for the next Q&A\n\nwhy western music is based on third? there is an historical reason or biological reason ? \nI mean for chords construction\n\nhi mum, i'm on a youtube video
ean
stop getting cuter, I do NOT want to develop a crush on you.
fatalkrash
He looks so much younger now, the hair and the clearer skin. Love learning more about music theory Adam!
fenderstratocaster
What's the HIGHEST note a human being can register? 🎵
hebercte
\
jogo3000
Those chord examples on the piano sound really good.
jojoyear
Hey adam. You look very healthy in this video. It might just be the hairstyle, but it looks like you got new cameras and/or lights and lost some weight as well. :)\n\nAnyway, great video, as always.
misotanni
Adam, the Star Wars theme is not in F major. It's in Bb major. Please.
oriskrk
Joke's on you, I remember every single aspect of All Star off by heart
rae cyn
my music teacher hates your videos lol but I love them keep it up dude
rmp5s
I'm NOT the only one that can't STAND that rhythm...good to know.
runescapefan17
-sadly- thankfully I already can audiate the subtleties of all stars bass
tharrock337
that is some highbrow liccing this time.
thegreatgambeeno
For audiation practice with writing - write out some small motifs, parts, and/or phrases away from the instrument. Just the basics, slurs aren't always necessary. Then grab your instrument, play what you've written. How close is it to what you have visualized? How far off is it? Try again, but not immediately, wait a few, maybe the later that day or the next. Try again. In time, I started getting closer and closer to writing my ideas only missing a note here and there by 1/2 steps usually. I now keep a notebook open at work in the kitchen all day. My new songs are now crusted in tomato juice and flour, brutal. It looks like blood at times. Metal.
two legged raccoon
Do you have a podcast? You totally should if you don’t
twostep919
With Adam, there is no delay!
v j g
hey Adam, do you think a musicians instrument colour choice will effect their image, say i owned a yellow bass would people take me less serious than if i owned a black and white bass like yours ? Obviously in a perfect world we would only be judged on our skill but people do often judge a book on their cover. love your vids keep up the good work - vince
you'r P I L E
Hey Adam do you find that your choice of bass limits you in any way? Not that there's anything wrong with a p-bass but i'd think that a bass with more features (for example Billy Sheehan's Yamaha bass) would provide for a larger tone pallet.Keep up the great videos! B A S S
원두Wondoo
Question for next Q&A: Hi Adam, I’m a bass player and also a pedal nerd. I saw you talking about upper octaver pedals—POG and Pitch Fork—on bass and became curious to know what do you think about Royal Blood, young british rock duo. \n\nTheir sound basically consists of multiple split channels of bass guitar sound with upper octavers, fuzz pedals and tube amps—it sounds awesome. In some interview, they said they view their bass and “guitar-ish” bass sounds in the relationship between snares and tom-toms, same intruments in different dimensions. \n\nI think their sound is somewhat similar to a brass ensemble in unison because of the harmonic richness of fuzz sound. Love your videos, and I’ll be happy to hear what you think about it. Thanks.